Public adjuster vs insurance adjuster vs lawyer vs roofer (Florida 2026)

Updated: Nov 3
It comes down to who signs their paycheck. The insurance company's adjuster is paid by the insurer, and a public adjuster is hired and paid by you, the policyholder. After Isaias you may hear from all four: the insurer's adjuster, a public adjuster, a roofer and maybe a lawyer.
Key takeaways
The insurer's adjuster reports to the insurance company, and a public adjuster works for the policyholder. The Florida Department of Financial Services licenses both.
A roofer or contractor cannot adjust or negotiate your claim unless the roofer also holds a public adjuster license.
A public adjuster cannot give legal advice or take part in repairing a property on a claim the adjuster handles.
You do not need a public adjuster, and the state says hiring one does not promise more money or a faster claim.
Who does what on a Florida property claim?
Insurer's adjuster | Public adjuster | Lawyer | Roofer or contractor | |
Works for | The insurance company | You, the policyholder | You, the client | You, for the repair work |
Who pays them | The insurer | You, as a percentage of the claim payment | You, under the fee agreement you sign | You, for the repair, under the repair contract |
License | Adjuster license from the Florida Department of Financial Services | Public adjuster license from the Florida Department of Financial Services | Member of The Florida Bar | Contractor license from the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation |
What they do on the claim | Inspects and reports to the insurer on what may be payable | Documents the damage, prepares the estimate and presents the claim to the insurer for you | Gives legal advice and can file a lawsuit | Repairs the property. Cannot handle the claim for you unless also licensed as a public adjuster |
When people call | Right away. You report the claim to your insurer | When the claim is large, the insurer's estimate looks low, or the paperwork piles up | When there is a legal question or the dispute may go to court | For emergency repairs and repair estimates |
What is the difference between a company adjuster and an independent adjuster?
Both work for the insurance company. A company adjuster is on the insurer's payroll. An independent adjuster works for an adjusting firm the insurer hires for the job. Either way, the report goes to the insurer.
Who does a public adjuster work for?
A public adjuster works for you. The Florida Department of Financial Services says a public adjuster does not work for or represent your insurance company.
A public adjuster builds the evidence file, prices the repair and argues the numbers with the insurer. You hire one with a written contract, and Florida law says you can still talk to your insurer directly at any time.
How is a public adjuster paid in Florida?
The fee is generally a percentage taken out of the insurance payment when it arrives. After a Governor-declared emergency, such as Isaias, Florida caps it at 10% for claims made during the following year. The fees page has the full rules and the exceptions.
Because the fee comes out of the payment, less of that money is left for repairs. Weigh that against what the adjuster adds to the claim.
Not sure which of the four you need for your claim? Call us, tell us what happened, and we will say plainly whether a public adjuster fits it. Call 954-466-5730
When is a public adjuster worth the fee?
The Department of Financial Services says hiring a public adjuster does not promise a higher payment or a faster claim. Call one when the damage is big, the estimate skips damage you can see, or the paperwork is burying you.
For a small claim the insurer has already paid in full, you may not need one.
Public adjuster or lawyer for a denied claim?
A public adjuster handles the claim and the numbers. A lawyer handles legal questions and lawsuits. Florida law does not allow a public adjuster to give legal advice.
If your claim was denied, start by asking the insurer for the denial and the policy reason in writing. Some disputes qualify for the state's insurance mediation program, run by the Department of Financial Services.
Can a roofer handle my insurance claim?
A roofer can only handle the claim with a public adjuster license as well. A contractor can repair the roof and explain the repair bid to you and your insurer. Florida law does not let a contractor adjust or negotiate the claim for you.
It works the other way too. Florida law bars a public adjuster from taking part in the repair of a property on a claim the adjuster handles.
How do I check a license?
Look up an adjuster or a public adjuster on the Florida Department of Financial Services licensee search. Contractors are on the Department of Business and Professional Regulation site. Lawyers are on The Florida Bar's member search.
Step by step: How to check a public adjuster in Florida before you hire.
More on Isaias claims: Hurricane Isaias insurance claims in Florida.
Talk to a licensed public adjuster
If an adjuster from the insurance company has already been out, tell us when, and what they looked at.
General information only. Coverage depends on your policy and the facts of your claim. Base Claims is not a law firm and does not give legal advice.
Base Claims Public Adjusters, 2400 NE 9th St, Hallandale Beach, FL 33009. Benji Licht, Licensed Public Adjuster, FL Lic. #W523574. Yossi Garber, Licensed Public Adjuster, FL Lic. #G173942.
THIS IS A SOLICITATION FOR BUSINESS. IF YOU HAVE HAD A CLAIM FOR AN INSURED PROPERTY LOSS OR DAMAGE AND YOU ARE SATISFIED WITH THE PAYMENT BY YOUR INSURER, YOU MAY DISREGARD THIS ADVERTISEMENT.





Comments