Best and worst home insurance companies in Florida for 2026: what the public data shows

Updated: Nov 4
Nobody publishes an official "best" or "worst" list for Florida home insurers. For 2026 the public measures are financial strength ratings and the state's list of companies taking policies out of Citizens, and this page gives each one with its source and date.
Base Claims in this post
Base Claims is a Florida public adjusting firm. We are not an insurance company or an insurance agent, and we do not sell insurance. No insurer paid to be listed or left out. We handle claims against many of these insurers for homeowners, so check the sources yourself before you buy.
Key takeaways
Citizens had 293,772 policies in force on May 31, 2026.
Twenty property and casualty companies have entered the Florida market since the 2022 and 2023 reforms, the state regulator said in May 2026.
Demotech and AM Best grade an insurer's finances. They say nothing about how it treats you on a claim.
Hurricane Helene produced 155,182 claims and about $2.58 billion in estimated insured losses, as of June 10, 2025.
How did we sort the insurers?
We used only data that a regulator or rating agency publishes, and each figure carries its source and date.
Financial strength rating. Demotech rates most Florida home insurers, and AM Best rates some. Demotech and AM Best grade an insurer's finances. They say nothing about how it treats you on a claim.
Citizens takeouts. The Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR) lists insurers approved to take policies out of Citizens Property Insurance, with dates.
We found no current public table of homeowner complaints by insurer, or of market share by insurer. Without one there is no sourced way to call any company the worst, so this page names none.
How big is Citizens in Florida now?
Citizens had 293,772 policies in force on May 31, 2026 (Citizens, monthly policies in force report). OIR put Citizens at 1.93% of Florida homeowners policies on March 31, 2026, with private insurers holding the rest (OIR Stability Report, July 2026).
OIR said in May 2026 that 20 property and casualty companies had entered the market since the 2022 and 2023 reforms (OIR news release, May 20, 2026).
Which insurers have Citizens takeouts in 2026?
OIR lists these insurers with Citizens takeout dates in 2026 (OIR take-out companies page, read October 16, 2026):
American Integrity Insurance Company
Apex Star Reciprocal Exchange
Florida Peninsula Insurance Company
Mangrove Property Insurance Company
Manatee Insurance Exchange
One Alliance North America Insurance Exchange
Patriot Select Property & Casualty Insurance Company
People's Trust Insurance Company
Praxis Reciprocal Exchange
Slide Insurance Company
Southern Oak Insurance Company
Stand Insurance Company
Universal North America Insurance Company
An approval lets that company offer to take over Citizens policies on those dates. It tells you nothing about claims handling or prices.
What are the financial strength ratings?
Demotech's site shows Slide Insurance Company with its financial stability rating affirmed on September 17, 2026, and Florida Family Insurance Company affirmed on September 14, 2026. For every other insurer, Citizens included, look up the current rating on Demotech or AM Best before you buy.
Ratings change. Demotech says only its most current rating applies, so check it on Demotech's site the day you buy.
What do we know about Hurricane Isaias claims so far?
OIR had not published Hurricane Isaias claim totals when we updated this page on October 16, 2026. We will add them when OIR posts them on its catastrophe reporting page.
For comparison, OIR reported 155,182 claims and about $2.58 billion in estimated insured losses for Hurricane Helene, as of June 10, 2025. It reported about $5.62 billion in estimated insured losses for Hurricane Milton, as of December 9, 2025. OIR reports these totals statewide and by county, not by insurer.
Hurricane claim steps for any insurer are on our hurricane damage claims page.
How do I choose a home insurance company in Florida?
Look up the financial strength rating on Demotech or AM Best on the day you buy.
Read the hurricane deductible. It is often a percentage of the dwelling coverage, such as 2%, 5% or 10%, rather than a flat amount.
Check what is left out. Most home policies exclude flood, which needs its own policy. Sinkhole coverage is usually separate too.
Ask how claims work. Ask the agent how to report one, and whether the company sends its own adjusters or independent ones after a storm.
Call the Department of Financial Services helpline at 1-877-693-5236 with questions about an insurer.
Benji Licht, the licensed public adjuster who runs Base Claims, puts the limit of any list plainly: "The company name alone does not tell you whether damage is covered." Your policy wording and the facts of the loss decide that.
Talk to a licensed public adjuster
Already in a claim with one of these companies after Isaias? Tell us the insurer and the stage your claim is at.
General information only. Coverage depends on your policy and the facts of your claim. Base Claims is not a law firm and does not give legal advice.
Base Claims Public Adjusters, 2400 NE 9th St, Hallandale Beach, FL 33009. Benji Licht, Licensed Public Adjuster, FL Lic. #W523574. Yossi Garber, Licensed Public Adjuster, FL Lic. #G173942.
THIS IS A SOLICITATION FOR BUSINESS. IF YOU HAVE HAD A CLAIM FOR AN INSURED PROPERTY LOSS OR DAMAGE AND YOU ARE SATISFIED WITH THE PAYMENT BY YOUR INSURER, YOU MAY DISREGARD THIS ADVERTISEMENT.





Comments